Highlights
- Despite billions invested in Western rare earth projects, the heavy rare earth (HREE) deficit—especially dysprosium and terbium—is structurally locked in for the next decade due to insufficient ore grades and capacity.
- MP Materials' Mountain Pass mine is fundamentally a light-REE operation with only marginal heavy-REE content, making claims of solving the HREE shortage strategically optimistic despite processing ambitions.
- China's dominance in heavy rare earths from ionic clay deposits remains unmatched, with price disparities (Dy oxide $900/kg in Rotterdam vs $255/kg in China) and export restrictions signaling geopolitical leverage over critical magnet materials.
A Reuters report captures a stark truth the West can no longer downplay: even with billions flowing into MP Materials, Lynas, Iluka, VAC, and others, the heavy rare earth (HREE) deficit is structurally baked into global supply for the next decade. Dysprosium and terbium—the heat-resistant backbone of high-performance magnets—remain the bottleneck. Mountain Pass offers only trace levels. Australia’s Mt. Weld produces limited volumes. And Brazil’s ionic clays, while promising, lag years behind in permitting, processing, and environmental acceptance.
Table of Contents
This core fact is accurate: the West is racing to build a magnet supply chain on a heavy-REE foundation it does not yet possess.
Rare Earth Exchanges (REEx) continues to focus on this mounting crisis. MP Materials has been on record that the California-based mine has 200t of SEG, and of course, the company is constructing a refining facility.
When Optimism Meets Ore Grades
MP Materials deserves credit for scaling light-REE output and building America’s first significant magnet plant in decades. But Reuters correctly highlights the weak link—Mountain Pass is fundamentally a light-REE mine. Claiming future HREE separation capacity is not the same as owning ore with meaningful dysprosium and terbium content. MP’s “several hundred tons” of medium/heavy concentrate containing 4% Dy/Tb is directionally plausible, but commercially marginal.
The article’s suggestion that MP can solve this gap with Brazilian or Malaysian material is partially true—but strategically optimistic. Securing off-take is one thing; securing geopolitical stability, ESG-compliant extraction, and multi-year processing capacity is another.
The Real Elephant: China’s Structural Advantage
Where Reuters plays it cautiously, REEx will say it plainly: China built an HREE empire from ionic clay deposits that the West does not have, at costs the West cannot match. Fastmarkets’ Dy oxide prices—$900/kg in Rotterdam vs. $255/kg in China—tell that story with brutal clarity.
No misinformation here—but one omission: China’s April 2025 export restrictions weren’t simply “controls.” They were a geopolitical warning shot, signaling that heavies are the new oil. The October “delay” is temporary optics, not détente.
The Long Road Out of the Hole
Lynas, Iluka, Torngat, Aclara, Northern Minerals, Brazilian Rare Earths, and VAC’s South Carolina plant show genuine momentum. But most new heavy-REE projects face slow ramp timelines, community opposition, or radioactive waste hurdles. This is the inconvenient accuracy Reuters touches but understates: HREEs are slow, messy, and expensive outside China, and the West’s 2030–2035 deficit projections remain severe.
The deeper investor signal? A heavy-REE crunch is not a risk—it is the base case.
Summary
REEx analyzes Reuters’ reporting on the Western heavy rare earth shortage, validating core facts, identifying optimistic assumptions, and placing developments in a broader supply-chain context. It clarifies strategic risks, ore-grade realities, geopolitical dynamics, and the multi-year challenge of scaling non-Chinese HREE capacity.
© 2025 Rare Earth Exchanges™ – Accelerating Transparency, Accuracy, and Insight Across the Rare Earth & Critical Minerals Supply Chain.
So, if you wanted to invest a small amount of money into a U.S. REE company, for long-term growth, (10-15 years), what would your recommendation/suggestion be ? ?