Highlights

• Pentagon invests $400M for 15% equity in MP Materials with $110/kg price floor guarantees and 10-year offtake commitments to build a 10,000-ton magnet facility by 2028.
• Apple commits $500M to purchase magnets from MP's Texas plant and partner on closed-loop recycling, securing non-Chinese supply for its 100% recycled rare earth strategy.
• Stock soars 400% in 2025, but execution risks loom: MP must build two factories simultaneously, exit China deals by 2026, and deliver on sky-high valuation expectations or face re-rating.

---

It begins with the Pentagon’s $400 million bet — price floors, magnets, and a mission. In July, MP Materials announced a landmark deal with the U.S. Department of Defense that catapults the company from miner to strategic asset. The Pentagon is investing $400 million for up to a 15% equity stake, instantly making the U.S. government MP’s largest shareholder. In return, MP must build a new magnet manufacturing “10X” facility to boost output to 10,000 metric tons per year by 2028 – a tenfold leap in domestic capacity. Crucially, the DoD deal de-risks this expansion with price floor guarantees: for the next 10 years, Washington will pay MP a minimum of$110 per kilogram for neodymium-praseodymium (NdPr) oxide and relatedmagnet materials. That floor is nearly double current Chinese market prices, ensuring MP a baseline revenue even if global rare earth prices slump. The Pentagon also agreed to buy or syndicate 100% of the new plant’s magnet output for a decade, virtually eliminating demand uncertainty. It’s an aggressive industrial policy play, effectively anointing MP as America’s rare earth magnet champion with marching orders to secure the supply chain. A supplemental $150 million DoD loan will help MP add heavy rare earth separation at its Mountain Pass site where and if feasible, addressing gaps in elements like dysprosium and terbium still sourced almost entirely from China and Myanmar as cited by Rare Earth Exchanges (REEx).  In July, JPMorgan and Goldman Sachs joined forces to arrange up to $1 billion (opens in a new tab) in commercial financing for MP — further validation that Wall Street now sees the rare earth supply chain as a national security asset. In sum, the government’s $400 million bet plus massive loans and a major deal with Apple enable the company to seek to forge a full-spectrum domestic magnet supply by 2028 – a “game changer” move to loosen China’s stranglehold.

Apple’s $500 M Circular Supply Chain Play

Not to be outdone, Apple Inc. stepped in as a marquee private-sector partner. In a first-of-its-kind arrangement, Apple signed a $500 million multi-year commitment to purchase high-performance rare earth magnets from MP’s Fort Worth, Texas factory. This deal doesn’t just funnel a major tech customer to MP – it pioneers a closed-loop supply chain. Apple and MP will build a rare earth recycling facility at Mountain Pass to process scrap electronics and end-of-life magnets into new material. Apple, which already uses 100% recycled rare earths in nearly all its device magnets, is betting on MP to help “strengthen the supply” of these critical materials in the U.S. per Apple (opens in a new tab) news entry.

The partnership marries Apple’s sustainability drive with MP’s manufacturing scale: special magnet production lines in Texas will be tailored for Apple products. This downstream vote of confidence signals robust demand for domestic magnets and a shift toward circularity in the supply chain. In fact, Apple’s deal reportedly includes substantial upfront payments to finance MP’s expansion, underscoring how eager end-users are to secure non-Chinese rare earth sources. The message is clear – from the Pentagon to Cupertino, heavyweights are investing in MP to ensure vital magnet supply is American-made, resilient, and sustainably sourced.

Execution Risks: Building Two Factories and Breaking China’s Chain

Despite these tailwinds, MP Materials now walks a strategic tightrope. The company must execute flawlessly on multiple fronts, or risk undermining its newfound mandate. Key execution risks include:

MP Materials: The Execution Gauntlet

Risk Theme	Summary	Strategic Implications
Twin Plant Tightrope	MP is building two magnet factories simultaneously — expanding its Texas “Independence” plant to 3,000 t/year while constructing the far larger 10,000 t/year “10X Facility.” Large concurrent projects stretch capital, labor, and management bandwidth.	Any engineering delay, cost overrun, or supply bottleneck could derail MP’s 2028 commissioning target and strain its balance sheet, testing whether the firm can truly scale from miner to industrial manufacturer.
Cutting Off Shenghe	As a condition of the DoD partnership, MP must terminate its offtake agreement with China’s Shenghe by 2026 — ending a once-stable revenue stream from concentrate exports.	MP loses its fallback option to sell to China, meaning any hiccup in domestic refining or magnet production could leave inventory stranded. The company now must execute flawlessly or risk idle product and lost cash flow.
Reliance on Uncle Sam	The company’s price floor ($110/kg NdPr) and offtake guarantees depend on ongoing Defense Production Act appropriations. Sustained federal support is essential to MP’s business model.	If Congress cuts or delays funding, MP could face liquidity gaps, project slowdowns, or even forced asset sales. The firm’s stability is partially political, tied to Washington’s will to maintain rare earth independence.
The Golden Leash	With the DoD now holding up to 15% equity, MP operates under tight government covenants — including restrictions on board composition, asset sales, and foreign ownership.	These controls cement MP as an American strategic asset but constrain its ability to pursue international partnerships or acquisitions. The company’s fate is now tethered to U.S. defense priorities — a patriotic advantage that doubles as a constraint.

National Champion or Single Point of Failure?

The Pentagon’s intervention undoubtedly crowns MP Materials as the de facto national rare earth champion (and REEx has often referred to the company and mine as a national treasure trove), but it also raises profound questions across the industry. As REEx analysts noted, this is “not a market-wide price floor” – it’s a bespoke deal for one company. Washington anointed MP and have sprinkled funding in a handful of others. But other firms may be left to fend for themselves.

Companies like EnergyFuels, Ucore, or even Australia’s Lynas (building its own U.S.plant) received no similar safety net, at least not as of yet.  This could change with Lynas for example with tomorrow’s meeting at the White House (Australia’s Prime Minister meets with President Trump).

Such asymmetry could concentrate risk rather than distribute resilience: MP is now insulated from price volatility, but its peers remain exposed to China’s notorious predatory pricing, which has driven past U.S. producers to bankruptcy. If those smaller players collapse or get acquired by foreign interests, America may end up with only one domestic source – a single point of failure for the supply chain it set out to secure per REEx assessment.

Even MP’s scope has limits. Mountain Pass mainly yields “light” rare earths (NdPr), while heavy rare earth elements like dysprosium, terbium, and samarium critical for high-performance magnets are still almost exclusively produced in China and Myanmar. The DoD-backed heavy separation project at MP is a start, but raw material for heavies remains scarce outside China’s orbit. So is MP’s Pentagon partnership the dawn of a self-sufficient rare earth ecosystem, or just the “quiet birth of a state-favored monopoly”? The answer will hinge on whether this bold experiment invites broader competition or unintentionally creates a bottleneck centered on MP alone.

Valuation: Sky-High Expectations

All this excitementhas sent MP’s stock into the stratosphere. Shares have soarednearly 400% in 2025, a meteoric rise fueled by the DoD and Apple deals and intensifying U.S.-China supply chain tensions. In mid-October the stock spiked into the $90s, reflecting a geopolitical premium on top of fundamentals. By traditional metrics, MP now trades at about 14× book value and well over 80× forward earnings, rarified levels for a materials company.

The market is pricing in years of future growth and an almost unassailable competitive position. Wall Street analysts peg a more sober fair value around $78 per share per REEx review of various analysts position, implying the current quote is running ahead of the consensus view of intrinsic worth. To justify this premium, MP will need to deliver near flawlessly on its promises. That means hitting its construction milestones and ramping magnet output to 10,000 tons by 2028, smoothly replacing Shenghe’s offtake with its own value-addedproduction, and turning today’s subsidies intotomorrow’s profits.

The company is expected to swing to profitability by 2026 as higher-margin magnet sales kick in and price-floor protections boost earnings. If MP can achieve those targets – effectively becoming the reliable linchpin of a non-China rare earth supply chain – its lofty valuation likely will be earned. But any stumble in execution or waning of political support, or other factors such as China making unorthodox and unexpected moves, could bring a harsh re-rating. The stakes, like the stock price, are sky-high. MP Materials, the nation’s rare earth treasure trove, has been handed a once-in-a-generation opportunity to cement itself as the cornerstone of America’s rare earth revival.

Now it must prove it can carry the weight of that crown – or risk being remembered as a cautionary tale of overreach. Either way, the world’s magnetsupply — and America’s industrial credibility —may hinge on what happens next at Mountain Pass.

©!-- /wp:paragraph -->