Highlights

• China dominates 85-90% of global rare earth refining and 90% of high-strength magnet production through decades of state investment, giving Beijing enormous leverage over defense, electronics, and green energy supply chains.
• Rare earth separation is technically complex and environmentally costly, requiring hundreds of extraction stages and deep expertise that China has mastered over decades while Western nations offshored this 'messy' process.
• Rebuilding U.S. rare earth processing capacity will take 5-10 years minimum due to severe knowledge gaps, environmental permitting challenges, and the time needed to construct and optimize complex chemical facilities at scale.

---

The United States faces a critical bottleneck in rare earth element (REE) separation and refining – a chokepoint that China overwhelmingly controls. Rare earths (a group of 17 elements) are essential for high-tech products from electric vehicle motors to missile guidance systems, yet the U.S. lacks domestic capacity to process them at scale.

China, by contrast, dominates this midstream stage, controlling roughly 85–90% of global rare earth refining capacity and about 90% of the world’s production of high-strength rare earth magnets.

This near-monopoly gives Beijing enormous leverage over supply chains for defense, electronics, and green energy technologies. The question is: how did the world arrive at this point, and why can’t the U.S. simply catch up overnight?

China’s Near-Monopoly in REE Processing

China’s grip on rare earth refining and magnet production did not happen by chance. Starting in the 1980s, China invested heavily in developing its rare earth industry – from mining to separation to finished magnets. Decades of state support, including subsidies for domestic refiners and lax environmental oversight, allowed Chinese producers to undercut competitors worldwide.

By the early 2000s, this strategy had driven others out of the market; for example, the U.S. Mountain Pass mine – once a leading rare earth source – collapsed in 2002 amid cheaper Chinese supply and environmental issues, effectively handing China control of the supply chain.

Today, even countries that mine rare earth ores (such as the U.S. and Australia) still send most of their output to China for refining, due to a lack of local processing facilities (although with the trade war commencing with incoming President Trump 2.0, nations in the West are accelerating efforts to achieve supply chain resilience—yet this will take time).

Beijing has leveraged this dominance strategically, at times restricting exports or flooding the market to influence prices and keep its edge. Crucially, China’s dominance extends to the manufacturing of neodymium-iron-boron (NdFeB) magnets, used in EV motors and wind turbines – it produces about 90% of these magnets globally.

Owning the entire chain from raw material to finished magnet gives China a powerful position that cannot be easily bypassed. China’s control of heavy rare earth mining, separation and magnet production hovers over 95%.

The Complex, Costly Art of Rare Earth Separation

Refining rare earths is technically challenging and environmentally arduous, which is a core reason the U.S. and others ceded this step to China. Unlike common metals, rare earth elements are usually found together in the same ore and have very similar chemical properties. Extracting them requires bespoke, multi-stage chemical processes to separate each element one by one.

See Rare Earth Exchanges “_Why Separating and Refining Rare Earth Elements is So Difficult to Scale_.”

The primary method, solvent extraction, involves hundreds of liquid-liquid extraction stages and chemical “tweaks” to gradually tease apart the elements. It’s an elaborate and delicate operation – a full separation plant can entail countless iterative cycles of acid baths, solvent mixers, and stripping stages to isolate high-purity REEs.

Minor errors in acidity, flow rate, or reagent mix can spoil the purity, meaning the process demands deep expertise and constant fine-tuning. As Rare Earth Exchanges has elucidated, Chinese engineers have mastered this art through decades of trial and error, developing an intuition for the minutiae of REE chemistry that is hard to replicate elsewhere.

The refining process is not only complex but also “messy” and polluting. Strong acids and organic solvents are used, generating toxic waste and often involving radioactive byproducts that must be contained.

For every ton of rare earth oxide produced, enormous volumes of waste rock and contaminated water are generated. China was willing to shoulder these environmental costs for decades – one reason Western countries were happy to offshore REE refining to China in the first place.

Strict environmental regulations in the U.S. and Europe make building and operating such refineries extremely expensive without heavy subsidies as we have reported. China’s comparatively lower regulatory constraints (especially in earlier decades) gave it a significant cost advantage.

In short, China “nailed down” the element-by-element separation process at industrial scale by combining technical prowess with a tolerance for the high costs – both financial and environmental – that the West was unwilling or unable to bear.

Years Needed to Bridge the Gap

Given the entrenched Chinese lead, the U.S. cannot overturn this bottleneck overnight. Rebuilding a full rare earth supply chain – from processing plants to skilled personnel to magnet factories – is a monumental task.

After decades of relying on China, the West now has a severe knowledge and talent gap in rare earth chemistry. As Rare Earth Exchanges has pointed out, only a handful of veteran specialists outside China know how to run large-scale separation operations, versus thousands of experts in China.

Rare Earth Exchanges reports that Beijing has even taken steps to guard its hard-won know-how, reportedly requiring rare earth technicians to register and restricting them from leaving the country to prevent technology leakage.

This means new Western projects often struggle to find the right expertise and must essentially start from scratch in developing processing know-how.

Even with abundant funding now being directed to “onshore” rare earth capabilities, new refineries and magnet plants take time to build and ramp up. Feasibility studies, permitting (especially given environmental hurdles), construction of complex chemical facilities, and the fine-tuning of processes can stretch on for years.

Analysts note that most announced Western rare earth processing projects “will take many years to come to fruition, “as cited in Reuters. In fact, establishing alternative refining capacity can take five to ten years in the best case, according to Rare Earth Exchanges' modeling.

For example, Australia’s Lynas Corp – currently the only significant non-Chinese refiner – spent years (with Japanese support) to perfect a single separation plant in Malaysia, and it still mainly handles light REEs.

Heavy rare earths like dysprosium and terbium (crucial for high-temperature magnets) remain especially challenging; until this year, no facility outside China had ever produced them at scale. To their credit Lynas has just started small amounts of heavy rare earth element exports to Japan.

The U.S. government and its allies are now funding projects to break this dependency, from reopening domestic mines to backing new separation technologies and recycling initiatives. Companies like MP Materials are building processing plants in the U.S., and research is ongoing into cleaner, faster separation methods.

However, these efforts are just beginning to chip away at a decades-long head start. Simply put, China’s rare earth refining juggernaut cannot be replaced overnight. It will take sustained investment, innovation, and training over the better part of this decade to diversify the supply chain even modestly.

Conclusion

Until those new facilities come online and prove themselves (at scale), the U.S. and other nations remain largely at the mercy of China’s rare earth pipeline. This enduring bottleneck underscores how far ahead China is in the “unsexy” but indispensable business of separating and refining the elements that power our modern world.

© 2025 Rare Earth Exchanges™ – Accelerating Transparency, Accuracy, and Insight Across the Rare Earth & Critical Minerals Supply Chain.