Highlights

• U.S. and Ukraine are negotiating a rare earth minerals deal that could reduce China's global mineral market control.
• The agreement involves complex geopolitical dynamics, including potential security concessions and Trump's negotiation strategy.
• Ukraine's mineral reserves are strategically valuable, but current mining and export capabilities remain limited.

---

Aamer Madhani, Associated Press (AP) reports (opens in a new tab) that in a dramatic shift in U.S.-Ukraine relations, the White House and Ukraine are closing in on a rare earth minerals deal that would grant the U.S. access to Ukraine’s critical resources while deepening bilateral ties. The negotiations, however, come after escalating tensions between President Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, with the former criticizing Ukraine’s handling of the war and dismissing Zelenskyy’s demands for security guarantees in exchange for the mineral access agreement.  The whole unfolding dynamic is yet another reminds of the classic approach Trump takes in “Art of the Deal.”

The breakthrough in negotiations was reportedly made during a three-day visit to Kyiv by Trump’s special envoy, retired Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg, who met with Zelenskyy and top Ukrainian officials. The deal—originally proposed by Zelenskyy last fall—was intended to strengthen Ukraine’s leverage against Russia. Yet, Trump’s administration has reframed it as a transactional agreement, with reports suggesting that Ukraine’s rare earth deposits may serve as “compensation” for past and future U.S. aid.  Again, the rare earths in Ukraine, while possibly valuable in the future, raise all sorts of issues. For one, at least 50% of the elements and minerals are located in Russian-held lands.

What’s at Stake?

Rare earth elements (REEs)—critical for smartphones, electric vehicles, and defense technologies—are overwhelmingly dominated by China. Gaining direct access to Ukraine’s mineral reserves would be a strategic win for Washington, reducing dependence on Beijing, or so AP suggests. But of course, this is not totally correct.   Rare Earth Exchanges has suggested such talk among the media covers more window dressing than substance.  Ukraine is many years away from economically mining, processing, and exporting such products.

The AP author raises questions. For example what concessions Ukraine is expected to make? This remains unclear, as does whether the deal includes military support or security guarantees—a top Ukrainian demand—has not been confirmed.

Russia and Saudi Arabia: Key Power Brokers?

Adding another layer of geopolitical intrigue, Trump’s team—including Secretary of State Marco Rubio and National Security Adviser Mike Waltz—recently held talks with Russian officials in Saudi Arabia. Trump has repeatedly pressured Zelenskyy to negotiate an end to the war, even suggesting that Putin “doesn’t have to make a deal” if he wants to take Ukraine entirely.

A Power Play in Global Trade?

With Europe, China, and the U.S. locked in a battle for critical minerals, this potential deal raises serious questions:

• Will Ukraine be forced into a resource-for-security tradeoff?
• How will this impact global rare earth markets, already dominated by China? The answer in the short run—not much to nil.
• Could Russia retaliate against Kyiv for moving closer to Washington economically?

As Zelenskyy cautiously signals optimism, at least according to Mr. Madhani, Trump’s hardball negotiations and dismissive rhetoric toward Ukraine’s survival raise concerns about the long-term stability of this agreement and whether Ukraine will truly benefit from the deal or simply be leveraged as another chess piece in Trump’s geopolitical maneuvering. Again, another way to look at the unfolding situation is via “Art of the Deal.”