Highlights

• USA Rare Earth (USAR) received regulatory approval to acquire UK-based Less Common Metals, the only proven non-Chinese producer of rare earth magnet metals at scale.
• The acquisition accelerates USAR's mine-to-magnet strategy.
• Despite having a $258 million cash supply-chain narrative, USAR remains pre-revenue with a $2.23/share TTM loss and negative profitability metrics.
• USAR has a $2.36 billion market cap for unproven operations.
• Material risks include unproven feedstock from Round Top and technology integration challenges at Stillwater.
• There is execution uncertainty, making USAR a high-beta development-stage bet rather than an operating producer.

---

USA Rare Earth Inc. (Nasdaq: USAR) just cleared the only regulatory hurdle for its acquisition of UK-based Less Common Metals (LCM), a rare earth metals and alloys producer serving defense, EV, semiconductor, and aerospace customers across the U.S., Europe, Japan, and Taiwan.

Zacks (opens in a new tab) frames the deal as a powerful accelerator of USAR’s “mine-to-magnet” strategy, alongside its Stillwater, Oklahoma NdFeB magnet plant (targeting first production in early 2026) and the Round Top rare earth deposit in Texas (Pre-Feasibility Study now pushed to H2 2026). The stock is up year-to-date and has outperformed its sector, though it still lags MP Materials and Energy Fuels.

From a supply-chain narrative perspective, the story is compelling: an American-listed name buying the only proven ex-China producer of both light and heavy rare earth magnet metals at scale.

Under the Hood: Pre-Revenue, Heavy Losses, Thin Float

Beneath the patriotic storyline, the numbers are stark:

• No revenue to date: net loss of $0.25/share in Q3, wider than the expected $0.06 loss and totaling about -$2.23/share (TTM).
• Negative profitability metrics: ROA ≈ –12%, ROE massively negative, EBITDA around –$39M.
• Cash-rich but unproven: ~$258M cash, negligible debt, strong current ratio (16.5), but a disclosed going-concern risk in filings.
• Valuation vs reality: a ~$2.36B market cap for a pre-revenue, technically complex, capital-intensive build-out.

Technically, USAR has rallied ~65% over 52 weeks, but trades well below its $43.98 high, with short interest near 7% of shares outstanding and ~10% of float, signaling meaningful skepticism and a very tight trading float that can amplify volatility.

Where the Narrative Overreaches

Zacks’ “Hold” conclusion is reasonable, but two material risks get soft-pedaled:

1. Feedstock risk – Round Top is not producing, and USAR lacks fully de-risked, long-term ore and heavy-REE separation at scale. LCM solves the metals/alloy link, not the upstream rock.
2. Technology and integration risk – USAR must prove it can:

• Commission Stillwater on time and budget,
• Integrate LCM without disrupting its legacy customer base, and
• Deliver commercial-grade magnets consistently for Enduro, ePropelled, and others.

For now, USAR looks less like a true mine-to-magnet player and more like an ambitious mid-market magnet and metals platform with unproven upstream and processing assumptions.

Existing holders may ride the strategic optionality; new investors should treat USAR as a high-beta, development-stage bet on U.S. industrial policy catching up to the spreadsheet.

© 2025 Rare Earth Exchanges™ – Accelerating Transparency, Accuracy, and Insight Across the Rare Earth & Critical Minerals Supply Chain.